Which wyatt earp movie is most historically accurate

But what i considered the weakest part of this movie and tombstone as well was the very incomplete. The absolute best historically accurate westerns val kilmer. The absolute best historically accurate westerns true west magazine. Its not as historically accurate as wyatt earp, but is the most exciting, and has better actors in the roles. Wyatt earp is too long, too boring, too true, but in fact it is the only earp movie that tries to do justice to time, place, and historical facts. The film tries to put an emphasis of hollidays important role in the justice sweep of wyatt earp and because of this it is not entirely historically accurate. Pic of kurt russell and val as wyatt earp and doc but westerns have never been great romance films. Most historically accurate film about ok corral gunfight. My wife picked up the dvd movie wyatt earp 1994 kevin costner, dennis quaid, gene hackman and we watched it yesterday evening.

Things like that bother me when seeing a supposedly historically accurate film. Wyatt earp, in full wyatt berry stapp earp, born march 19, 1848, monmouth, illinois, u. We both enjoyed it a lot, even though it was on the lengthy side about 3 hrs, i think. The details of the actual gunfight arent all that exciting, at least compared to what modern audiences usually expect in such films. Most wyatt earp films are pretty much straightforward. In the battle of the western biopics, does tombstone or wyatt earp emerge victorious. Things like that bother me when seeing a supposedly historically accurate. He was named after his fathers commanding officer in the mexicanamerican war, captain wyatt berry stapp, of the 2th company illinois mounted volunteers. Wyatt earp is an old west lawman who became immortalized after the firefight at the o. Which of these three films on wyatt earp and the o. In all the other movies about wyatt earp theres never mention of this organized crime gang called the cowboys, red sashes, and wyatt earp chasing them all down and killing them one by one. There are many people saying the movie wyatt earp was more historically accurate than tombstone but i beg to differ, especially regarding the.

These are the amazing photographs of some of the most notorious prostitutes in. Tombstone 1993tombstone movietombstone arizonawestern filmwestern. He visited with the town council and made what he thought was an offer they wouldnt be able to refuse. The 10 best movies about wyatt earp and doc holliday. The absolute best historically accurate westerns true west. Although you probably wouldnt want to write a collegelevel history paper based on the facts in this movie either. But even though tombstone would begin filming more than two months before the start of wyatt earp. Wyatt earp is on target historically, but forces its hand emotionally by kenneth turan june 24, 1994. Blake edwards movie sunset is based on earps hollywood years.

The absolute best historically accurate westerns when hollywood got it right. Kurt russell, val kilmer, bill paxton, and sam elliott, among many others. It stars kevin costner in the title role as the lawman of the same name, and features an ensemble cast that includes gene hackman, mark harmon, michael madsen, bill pullman, dennis quaid, isabella rossellini, tom sizemore, jobeth williams, mare winningham and jim. Tombstone and wyatt earp were two bigbudget western biopics released within six months of each other, but which movie is the best. Wyatt earp, two westerns released six months apart, both of which hinged. But i agree with poster thbryn, why are we getting bogged down on this subject. Kevin costners film, wyatt earp is the most historically accurate.

The 10 best movies about wyatt earp and doc holliday taste of. Unforgiven is a work of pure fiction, yet is so powerful, that the movie is one of only three. The film is not very accurate on historical facts a major change of history is that of doc holliday being killed before the gunfight at the o. But what i considered the weakest part of this movie and tombstone as well was the very incomplete and weak buildup to the gunfight. Wyatt berry stapp earp was born on march 19, 1848, the fourth child of nicholas porter earp and his second wife, virginia ann cooksey. The op is basically right that costners wyatt earp is the most historically accurate recounting of the gunfight at the ok corral as far as we can know. Some evidence supports wyatt earps birthplace as 406 s. Which is the most historically accurate western film, and why. Nose kate, is an indication of the films interest in historical accuracy. Walt disney studios set to work on an earp movie based on a script by. A few tell the story from points of view different from earps but this movie concentrates on the location of the whole story. Impressive but uninviting, wyatt earp is easier to admire from a distance. The story of wyatt earp is one of the most popular, and yet inaccurately.

If you have not seen this movie yet, please make tracks to your local video store. Costner made a visit to the actual tombstone, arizona way before filming ever started. Wyatt earps most brilliant part is the entire setting including costumes, locations, and capturing the entire era of any era. A few westerns we are celebrating were small at the box office, but played big, at least to those of us who like and appreciate portrayals of an authentic, nitty gritty old west. The film is not very accurate on historical facts a major change of history. These are the amazing photographs of some of the most notorious prostitutes in the wild west and women.

That was a remark that was overheard between those two by an eyewitness on oct 26, 1881. My question is, how historically accurate is this movie. This early wyatt earp movie, based on stuart lakes book frontier. Wyatt earp is good, as is hour of the gun, but tombstone is the best, in my opinion. I dont know much about the history of the wild west, but it seemed to have a feel of authenticity that. Interestingly enough, costner was involved in both wyatt earp movies.